UK Court Rules Against India in RAKIA Investment Dispute


|

UK Court Rules Against India in RAKIA Investment Dispute
UK Court Rules Against India in RAKIA Investment Dispute
The English Court of Appeal dismisses India's appeal over a bauxite supply agreement dispute with Ras Al Khaimah Investment Authority.

The English Court of Appeal has rejected India's appeal concerning a dispute related to Ras Al Khaimah Investment Authority (RAKIA) under the India-UAE Bilateral Investment Treaty. This decision follows an earlier ruling that allowed the dispute to proceed before an arbitral tribunal.

The conflict centres on a canceled bauxite supply agreement linked to an aluminium project in Andhra Pradesh, involving RAKIA and the Penna Group. India's efforts to challenge the arbitral tribunal's jurisdiction were dismissed, allowing RAKIA's claims to advance.

In 2007, a memorandum of understanding was signed between the Government of Andhra Pradesh and the Government of Ras Al Khaimah, facilitating the establishment of an alumina refinery, aluminium smelter, and power plant. RAKIA invested approximately $42.5 million in ANRAK Aluminium Limited, which was created to implement this project. Over time, RAKIA's share in the project was diluted to about 12% after public protests prompted a reversal in the state government's position in 2015, leading to the termination of the bauxite supply agreement by Andhra Pradesh Mineral Development Corporation (APMDC).

RAKIA initiated arbitration against India in December 2016. They alleged violations of the investment treaty, claiming that India failed to provide fair treatment and unlawfully expropriated RAKIA's investment. An arbitral tribunal initially ruled in May 2022 that it lacked jurisdiction over the matter, stating that the government actions primarily affected ANRAK and APMDC, with only indirect implications for RAKIA.

However, in June 2025, the English High Court overturned this decision. The High Court asserted that government actions targeting a company could impact a foreign investor's interests, regardless of the shareholding structure. India argued that RAKIA’s investment was limited to its shares in ANRAK, downplaying the significance of project-oriented decisions. The Court of Appeal, however, maintained that the India-UAE Bilateral Investment Treaty must be viewed within its economic context, preserving the protections afforded to investments.

The Court also rejected India's interpretation of the treaty that only direct government actions aimed specifically at RAKIA’s investment should be considered. Instead, the Court articulated that the treaty covers actions that directly impact the broader investment context.

As a result, the dispute is set to proceed before the arbitral tribunal, which will examine whether India breached the treaty and if compensation is owed to RAKIA. Legal representatives for India and RAKIA included notable figures from well-known law firms Dentons and Freshfields, respectively.

Trump, Putin, and Xi to Meet at APEC Summit in Shenzhen, China
Trump, Putin, and Xi to Meet at APEC Summit in Shenzhen, China
The US, Russia, and China leaders will convene to discuss nuclear weapons and security issues during next week's APEC summit.
|
Congress Criticises Adani for Dramatic Cost Cut in Maharashtra Project
Congress Criticises Adani for Dramatic Cost Cut in Maharashtra Project
The Congress party raises concerns over Adani's significant reduction in costs for the Maharashtra power project, calling it a major scandal.
|
Urban Infrastructure Crucial for India's Manufacturing Growth
Urban Infrastructure Crucial for India's Manufacturing Growth
India's manufacturing sector growth hinges on urban demand through infrastructure projects, says World Bank's Neelkanth Mishra.
|
India Extends Ban on Zakir Naik's Islamic Research Foundation
India Extends Ban on Zakir Naik's Islamic Research Foundation
The Indian government has renewed the ban on Zakir Naik's Islamic Research Foundation for five years, citing security concerns.
|
BJP's Manoj Tiwari Responds to Raj Thackeray’s Chhath Festival Claims
BJP's Manoj Tiwari Responds to Raj Thackeray’s Chhath Festival Claims
Manoj Tiwari of the BJP rebuts Raj Thackeray's remarks on Chhath celebrations, highlighting local community support in Maharashtra.
|